Friday, 13 December 2013

WINOL Final Year Critical Reflection

In our fourth consecutive year, Winchester News Online has continuously developed, progressed and flourished as a fully functional editorial student run project.  Excelling across news, sport, features, web and production as a team we have been accredited as one of the best BJTC courses for journalism. Our success across all media outlets has been acknowledged as we have achieved awards for both Website of the Year and overall Best TV News-day of the Year.

This semester we have particularly focused on our online media outlets such as our website and twitter feeds to expand and establish our audience. WINOL’s circulation figures are significantly better than last year with our current Alexa ranking of 30, 063 in the UK as of 6/12/13. We have continuously competed in the Alexa rankings making us one of the most viewed student journalist sites nationally but also with larger audiences than local news outlets such as The Hampshire Chronicle and the Daily Echo. The most recent figures show that WINOL is ranking higher than East
London Lines with our record day rating standing at an impressive 2,737 web views.  

On the whole WINOL has massively improved however we are still ranking below JMU and Leeds universities which could be because of our range of stories and style of writing. Throughout the semester, the news team have been advancing their skills with camerawork, editing and scripting although the quality of writing has not improved at the same rate as the quality of the video packages. There have been quite a few problems with written stories this term as they are often rushed and put up at the last minute leaving subs a tough job of editing the stories with reporters often turning in scripts. As a solution to this problem a ‘Subs Bible’ was produced that outlined and explained what content to include and how to structure stories correctly.

Although WINOL has been extremely successful, consistently hitting deadlines and producing accomplished and varied content each week it does have its flaws. One of the main problems that many guest editors have mentioned seems to be our lack of a specific audience. ‘What target audience are we trying to reach?’ is a repeatedly asked question not just from a content point of view but also on a marketing/distribution scale. The lack of a clear target audience left us questioning whether we were aiming to be a local news outlet for Winchester or just for students at the university as our audience seems to be made up of people that have been involved in WINOL either through interviews or because of the stories that have been broadcasted. I think the problem lies within the bulletin and not the individual packages so it is a key aim for next year to generate an audience that tunes in to watch us as their regular news update.

The news team have done exceptionally well this year, with reporters adjusting to taking on important lead roles such as news editor for the week as well as organising and directing second years on their packages. As a local output WINOL has hit the target on numerous occasions focusing on stories with a clear local angle that will appeal to viewers in the Hampshire area. Last year we were extremely lucky with our content as we covered the breaking news story of the Eastleigh-by-election and other important events such as the Budget which advanced us and our reputation as a professional news channel. One of the only breaking stories we attempted to cover was the BAE job losses which could have been developed a bit more, as at the time the workers were protesting however the initial story broke on a Wednesday and after failed attempts at trying to travel down to Portsmouth we utilised a link up from the studio to the newsroom to discuss the developing events. It was a shame that we couldn’t report live from the location as it would have pulled in a huge amount of hits from one of Hampshire’s biggest news items as it was so relevant to the local area.

WINOL always strives to cover a range of news stories, from crime, health and business, to political and environmental it is essential that we maintain a varied news bulletin. Each reporter has always aimed for an interesting story with many producing a detailed and well shot package for the week, with some particularly standing out at an exceptionally accomplished level. Matt Spencer’s involvement with the police and crime commissioner in Hampshire and the West Midlands has been a credit to him and to WINOL as he was the first student to be asked to produce and broadcast the COMPASS meeting that was held in our studios.
As a more experienced student, Christina Michael’s has excelled as a crime reporter producing packages with a composed nature yet still conveying a gripping story with legitimate facts and images; in particular the rape story was shot perfectly with a professional piece to camera.

When it came to shooting a package and the editing of visuals and the audio, students such as Liam Garrahan and Ellen Millard have frequently excelled in this area, producing clear, structured and visually engaging reports with a variety of angles, raw natural sound, sequences and solid interviews. In particular Liam’s package on changes to scrap metal laws has been described as the ‘best student news package to date’ and is now used as a template for other students to follow.

In terms of WINOL’s video output it was a bit hit and miss with the quality as there was a clear divide in experience amongst the team. The lack of communication and direction also effected how packages were edited and then uploaded as there were a host of technical issues that continued to cause problems with VTs. Shots were out of focus or over exposed and a lack of GV and sequence shots also left reporters with little to work with when editing. Interviews were also an issue for a while whether it was visually or because of audio there seemed to be no real quotes used; people would instead opt for exposition which should be done in a voiceover over visuals.

The features section has also been incredibly successful this year as it has been directed at a student audience with aesthetically engaging content on fashion, technology and entertainment. As an added extra, Winchester Access has been introduced which brings viewers the latest reviews on events happening around the area as well as interviews with TV personalities, exclusive previews of theatrical shows, film festivals and the latest developments in technology, all of which appeal and attract a student audience. The fashion magazine, Absolute:ly focuses on our female readership with articles on fashion,  hair and beauty as well as an exclusive interview with Rosie Mullender; feature editor of Cosmopolitan magazine.

My role on WINOL this year has been as a reporter for Winchester Access, a new feature led bulletin produced each week.  For the first Access we decided to set our aims high by travelling up to London to cover the Rain Dance film festival. As it was the first week we only had two items for the bulletin, the film festival and an African drumming lesson. For our first go, we saw it as a draft, a work in progress that could only evolve and develop until we established a set way of producing, filming and editing. The presenting had to be edited thoroughly to energise the piece, we did this by speeding up certain clips to keep the piece moving however the overall footage was poorly lit and had extensive audio issues. As the presenter for the Rain Dance package it was a challenge getting into a lively, natural mind set where you have to walk through areas of the event and use extensive hand movements to engage the viewer. The African drumming was better, however it was too much of a puff piece, Jack needed to make the review as honest as possible, with the idea to poke fun but in a disarming way.

For the second week we had more content for the bulletin, Jack helped to film a coffee house session which involved local artist, Ben Goddard performing in the student union. I travelled to Southampton with Faith Thomas where we gained exclusive access to a press launch of War Horse; we managed to get some brilliant shots of the puppet in motion and two different interviews with the puppeteers and the musician. I decided to have another go at presenting and felt I achieved a more natural presence when on camera as well as slowing down my pace when speaking. The show still lacked a set structure; we needed an opening to the show that gave the audience a preview of what was coming up that included a headline clip.

Over the next few weeks we developed Access into a set structure with opening titles, headlines, graphics and music that became unique to our bulletin. The content became more varied as we became more confident, setting up interviews and getting exclusive access by making the effort to pursue calls and emails to get us into places.
We also started to expand the bulletin by including reviews on films and technology that were produced by people outside of the team, for example Liam produced a fantastic package on the Apps World convention in London for week four. Here he looked at apps, new games and new technology and it was the first time we had presented somewhere on location. Jack and Liam dual presented the show opting to avoid a script as it would seem more natural to riff off one another which received a great amount of praise.

When it came to week five we produced a Halloween special that received the most hits as we set up our own twitter account that week, which we used to promote the bulletin. We opted for a Gothic and typically spooky look by filming the presenting in the graveyard as well as changing the lighting on final cut and adding in a rain effect which visually made it dark and gloomy. That week Faith and I went on a ghost walk which we were allowed to film, however due to it being late at night and some technical issues the footage didn’t come out as well as we hoped due to the lack of lighting. Luckily because of the style of the bulletin we could add in extra effects and edit the footage in the style of “Most Haunted”.

Overall I have enjoyed reporting on Access with many of my packages turning out well, particularly the Winchester film festival where I went and reported in the Art CafĂ©. I got a variety of shots with different angles and a solid interview that added variety and depth to the piece. It gave me a good chance to work on my piece to camera as I presented the package on location which looked effective as the viewers can see that I’m getting involved and experiencing the event myself.  Another package I really enjoyed filming was the charity event for Parkinson’s UK at Winchester Cathedral. We gained exclusive access and were allowed to film inside, giving us some fantastic shots of the choir singing in the cathedral. Unfortunately I had audio issues when filming the interview with the event manager, this was a shame as the interview was shot well and had some good quotes. In the end I tried to edit the sound as much as possible but couldn’t use it because the quality was so poor.

As the weeks have progressed so has Access, with nine bulletins in total we have strived to improve each week, using effects, graphics, music and working on our presenting, audio and camera work. In week nine, our penultimate show you can see how far the bulletin has come and how we have all worked together as a team to set a high quality and professional standard for those taking over the role next year.

Each semester WINOL grows as a project, with advanced reporting, accomplished packages and professional production it is one of the best learning resources any journalism student could ask for. As an individual I feel I have strengthened my camera work and editing skills as well as growing in confidence when attending events and presenting for the camera. WINOL thrives off teamwork, dedication and recognition which makes it an incredibly professional news channel that everyone who has participated in this semester, should be proud of.


Word Count 2100

No comments:

Post a Comment